Federal Fiscal Court (BFH) Input tax deduction: New ruling published on November 19, 2026 – tax office cannot simply disallow it!

A supplier evades VAT – and suddenly his customer is also supposed to lose his input tax deduction? The Federal Fiscal Court has set limits for the tax office. The ruling VR 31/25 strengthens the rights of businesses that are denied input tax deduction due to tax evasion by their business partners.

Frankfurt am Main
November 22, 2026
You purchase goods for your business. The delivery actually takes place, the sales tax is correctly invoiced, and you claim the input tax deduction.
Years later, the tax investigation unit discovers that your supplier has evaded VAT. The tax office subsequently revokes your input tax deduction and demands a back payment.
But can you be held responsible for tax evasion by your supplier that has nothing to do with your delivery of goods?
That is precisely what the Federal Fiscal Court has ruled on.
Federal Fiscal Court (BFH) Input tax deduction: What did the court decide?
In its judgment of July 16, 2026, VR 31/25 , published on November 19, 2026 , the Federal Fiscal Court clarified:
Tax evasion by the supplier does not automatically justify the denial of input tax deduction to the customer.
The crucial question is whether the tax evasion is actually related to the specific supply chain.
Regardless of the above, if the supplier has evaded VAT, for example through fictitious invoices for alleged purchases of goods, this alone is not sufficient to deny his customer the input tax deduction.
The case: Precious metals, bogus invoices and tax evasion
In 2012, a limited liability company (GmbH) purchased precious metals from another limited liability company (GmbH). The goods were indeed delivered. The buyer claimed the VAT as input tax.
It later turned out that the supplier's managing director had been convicted of tax evasion.
He had claimed input tax credits for his company based on fictitious invoices from two other companies. These companies had not actually delivered the precious metals for which they had allegedly invoiced.
The tax office drew a far-reaching conclusion from this: it also denied the buyer of the precious metals the input tax deduction.
The reasoning: The buyer should at least have recognized that her supplier was involved in VAT fraud.
The Münster Tax Court upheld this view. However, the Federal Fiscal Court identified a crucial error.
Why the tax office cannot simply refuse input tax deduction
The Federal Fiscal Court distinguishes between two completely different situations.
Case 1: Tax evasion within the supply chain
A business owner purchases goods whose delivery is part of a VAT fraud scheme. If he knows about this, or should have known about it based on objective circumstances, the input tax deduction can be denied.
Case 2: Tax evasion outside the supply chain
The supplier sells goods that actually exist and declares this revenue correctly. However, he independently claims input tax credits based on fictitious purchase invoices.
In this case, the supplier's tax evasion alone is not sufficient to deny the buyer the input tax deduction.
The Münster tax court failed to adequately consider precisely this distinction. The two companies that allegedly sold precious metals to the supplier were not, in fact, part of the supply chain. Their names merely appeared on the fictitious invoices. A single incorrect accounting entry does not transform a non-existent supply relationship into a genuine supply chain.
Are businesses required to check their suppliers for tax evasion?
The ruling contains another important statement for practical application.
Businesses are not generally required to check whether their suppliers fulfill all tax obligations.
In particular, they are not generally obliged to check whether the invoice issuer has submitted their VAT returns or paid their VAT to the tax office.
However, this does not mean a free pass.
If there are specific irregularities in connection with a delivery, further investigations may be necessary.
However, VAT law does not require a comprehensive review of the supplier's entire tax history.
Has the Federal Fiscal Court definitively granted the input tax deduction?
No. That is an important distinction. The Federal Fiscal Court overturned the ruling of the Münster Fiscal Court and referred the legal dispute back.
The tax court must now examine whether VAT was potentially evaded at another, actually existing stage of the supply chain. This is because it remains unclear from whom the supplier actually obtained the precious metals.
If tax evasion has occurred, it must also be examined whether the buyer knew about it or should have known about it.
However, one thing is already certain: The supplier's fictitious invoices alone do not justify the denial of input tax deduction.
What does the new Federal Fiscal Court ruling mean for entrepreneurs?
The ruling is particularly interesting for companies that have been denied input tax deduction by the tax office due to alleged involvement in VAT fraud.
In such cases, it is crucial which specific deliveries were affected by the tax evasion.
The mere finding that a business partner has evaded taxes is not sufficient.
The tax office must assess the conditions for a fraud-related denial of input tax deduction based on the specific turnover.
Anyone who receives a corresponding tax assessment should therefore check whether the tax office has actually established a connection between the tax evasion and their own delivery. If the assessment is not yet legally binding, the new Federal Fiscal Court ruling can be an important starting point for substantiating an appeal.
Conclusion: Tax evasion by the supplier is not automatically your problem
The Federal Fiscal Court draws an important line.
Entrepreneurs should not lose their input tax deduction simply because a business partner has evaded VAT, regardless of the specific supply chain.
The denial of input tax deduction due to participation in VAT fraud depends on the connection with the actual turnover.
The BFH ruling published on November 19, 2026, thus provides an important argument against blanket reductions in input tax by the tax office.
Source:
Further current decisions and information on tax law can be found in the TaxPro Newsblog .



